* Jesse P. Eddy III 1940
* Arthur B. Rawcliffe 1940
* Alfred B. Lemon 1941
* William F. Culton 1941
* Henry T. Cook 1942
* George O. Whitehead 1942
* Franklin N. Crowell 1943
* George H. Lenth 1943
* Raymond E. Jordan 1944
* Harold O. E. Casperson 1944
* Russell R. Hunt 1945
* William E. Sleight 1945
* + Stanley W. Matthews 1946
* Clayton B. Smith 1946
* Robert B. Jones 1947
* Preston H. Page 1947
* Charles C. Horton 1948
* Richard A.F. Ballou 1948
* Robert F. Eddy 1949
* Herbert E. Murch 1949
LEGEND: *= Deceased/ +=
Demitted / PGM= Past Grand Master